Free Shipping + Returns On Domestic Orders!

Gift Ideas Under $2500

  • Sort by

  • Shop by Gemstone

  • Shop by Metal

BVLGARI Estate 18kt Abstract "Heart" 2-Tone Ring w/ Box BVLGARI Estate 18kt Abstract "Heart" 2-Tone Ring w/ Box Quick View

BVLGARI Estate 18kt Abstract "Heart" 2-Tone Ring w/ Box

$1,295

This fabulous estate ring is a signed piece by Bvlgari! Made of 18kt gold, this unique ring has a simple and attractive abstract "heart" design. Th...
Art Deco 14kt Carved Rock Crystal, Pearl & Onyx Earrings Art Deco 14kt Carved Rock Crystal, Pearl & Onyx Earrings Quick View

Art Deco 14kt Carved Rock Crystal, Pearl & Onyx Earrings

$1,495

A beautiful pair of carved rock crystal earrings from the Art Deco (ca1920) era! These stunning earrings are most likely of Chinese decent and hav...
Early Victorian Rare 18kt Ruby Diamond & Enamel Checkerboard Ring Early Victorian Rare 18kt Ruby Diamond & Enamel Checkerboard Ring Quick View

Early Victorian Rare 18kt Ruby Diamond & Enamel Checkerboard Ring

$1,995

A very unusual ring from the Early Victorian (ca1850s) era! This unique ring is crafted in vibrant 18kt gold, displaying a striking checkerboard m...
Victorian 14kt Mixed Metals Floral Tassel Earrings Victorian 14kt Mixed Metals Floral Tassel Earrings Quick View

Victorian 14kt Mixed Metals Floral Tassel Earrings

$1,395

A beautiful pair of hanging tassel earrings from Victorian (ca1880) era! Each of these artistic earrings is crafted in 14kt gold, and has a mixed m...
Art Deco 14kt Champagne Diamond Cluster Ring .65ct center Art Deco 14kt Champagne Diamond Cluster Ring .65ct center Quick View

Art Deco 14kt Champagne Diamond Cluster Ring .65ct center

$1,695

A beautiful diamond cluster ring from the Art Deco era (ca1930s)! This gorgeous ring is crafted in 14kt white and yellow gold, and has a diamond e...
TIFFANY & CO. Estate 18kt Diamond "Etoile" Huggy Hoop Earrings TIFFANY & CO. Estate 18kt Diamond "Etoile" Huggy Hoop Earrings Quick View

TIFFANY & CO. Estate 18kt Diamond "Etoile" Huggy Hoop Earrings

$2,395

A gorgeous pair of estate Tiffany & Co. "Etoile" earrings! Each earring is made of vibrant 18kt gold, and has a stylish "huggy" hoop design. F...
Edwardian 18kt Mine Cut Diamond 3-Stone Cluster Ring 1ctw Edwardian 18kt Mine Cut Diamond 3-Stone Cluster Ring 1ctw Quick View

Edwardian 18kt Mine Cut Diamond 3-Stone Cluster Ring 1ctw

$1,595

A beautiful diamond cluster ring from the Edwardian (ca1910) era! Crafted in 18kt white gold, this lovely ring holds 3 Mine Cut diamonds at the cen...
Sale
Victorian 14kt Sparkle Copper Jasper & Micro Mosaic Bird Earrings Victorian 14kt Sparkle Copper Jasper & Micro Mosaic Bird Earrings Quick View

Victorian 14kt Sparkle Copper Jasper & Micro Mosaic Bird Earrings

$1,995 $2,395

An exquisite and unusual pair of micro mosaic earrings from the Victorian (ca1880) era! Each earring frames two jasper stones within a curvy 14kt g...
Edwardian Platinum French Cut Diamond Eternity Band .50ctw Edwardian Platinum French Cut Diamond Eternity Band .50ctw Quick View

Edwardian Platinum French Cut Diamond Eternity Band .50ctw

$1,595

A gorgeous diamond eternity band from the Art Deco (ca1920) era!  Made of platinum, this feminine ring displays a row of sparkling French Cut diam...
Victorian 14kt Mine Cut Diamond Crescent Moon Pendant 1.75ctw Victorian 14kt Mine Cut Diamond Crescent Moon Pendant 1.75ctw Quick View

Victorian 14kt Mine Cut Diamond Crescent Moon Pendant 1.75ctw

$2,995

A gorgeous crescent moon pendant from the Victorian era (ca1880)! Beautiful old Mine Cut diamonds line the surface of the crescent, which is craft...
Sale
Art Nouveau 14kt Tourmaline & Diamond Lavalier Pendant Art Nouveau 14kt Tourmaline & Diamond Lavalier Pendant Quick View

Art Nouveau 14kt Tourmaline & Diamond Lavalier Pendant

$1,995 $2,995

A gorgeous lavalier pendant from the Art Nouveau (ca1900) era! This lovely piece is made of 14kt gold, and has an elegant chandelier design. The pe...
Edwardian Platinum Diamond Hearts Eternity Band .30ctw Edwardian Platinum Diamond Hearts Eternity Band .30ctw Quick View

Edwardian Platinum Diamond Hearts Eternity Band .30ctw

$1,295

A beautiful diamond eternity band from the Retro (ca1930) era! This lovely platinum ring has a romantic hearts motif. Sparkling single cut diamonds...
Retro 14kt Sapphire Eternity Bands 2-Piece Ring Set Retro 14kt Sapphire Eternity Bands 2-Piece Ring Set Quick View

Retro 14kt Sapphire Eternity Bands 2-Piece Ring Set

$1,595

A stunning pair of sapphire eternity bands from the Retro (ca1940s) era! These matching rings are crafted in 14kt white gold and are lined with be...
LARTER Edwardian Platinum/14kt Diamond 9-Piece Cufflink Set LARTER Edwardian Platinum/14kt Diamond 9-Piece Cufflink Set Quick View

LARTER Edwardian Platinum/14kt Diamond 9-Piece Cufflink Set

$1,395

A lovely 9-piece cufflink set by Larter & Sons from the Edwardian (ca1910) era! The ensemble includes a pair of cufflinks and 7 matching shirt...
Victorian 18kt Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings 1.25ctw Victorian 18kt Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings 1.25ctw Quick View

Victorian 18kt Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings 1.25ctw

$2,195

A gorgeous pair of diamond earrings from the Victorian (ca1880) era! These beautiful studs feature a cluster of sparkling diamonds held within an 1...
Art Deco 14kt Black Opal Ring Art Deco 14kt Black Opal Ring Quick View

Art Deco 14kt Black Opal Ring

$1,795

Black opals are among the most rare and valuable of all natural opal varieties. Unlike their common opal counterparts, they have a dark canvas and ...
Victorian 14kt Large Enamel Tiger Pendant Victorian 14kt Large Enamel Tiger Pendant Quick View

Victorian 14kt Large Enamel Tiger Pendant

$1,895

A magnificent enameled pendant from the Victorian (ca1880) era! Crafted in vibrant 14kt gold, the piece represents the 3-dimensional repousse face...
Arts & Crafts Sterling/14kt Moonstone & Emerald Ring Arts & Crafts Sterling/14kt Moonstone & Emerald Ring Quick View

Arts & Crafts Sterling/14kt Moonstone & Emerald Ring

$1,395

A very unusual ring from the Arts & Crafts era (ca1910)! Crafted in sterling silver, the ring has a decorative design that frames a moonstone ...
Victorian 14kt Etruscan White Opal & Seed Pearl Earrings Victorian 14kt Etruscan White Opal & Seed Pearl Earrings Quick View

Victorian 14kt Etruscan White Opal & Seed Pearl Earrings

$1,295

An impressive pair of Etruscan opal earrings from the Victorian (ca1880) era! These incredible handmade earrings are crafted in 14kt gold, and are ...
Victorian 14kt/Sterling Emerald & Rose Cut Diamond Ring .40ct Victorian 14kt/Sterling Emerald & Rose Cut Diamond Ring .40ct Quick View

Victorian 14kt/Sterling Emerald & Rose Cut Diamond Ring .40ct

$1,295

A simply beautiful gemstone cluster ring from the Victorian era (ca1880)! Crafted in 14kt gold, the setting is topped in sterling silver, creating ...
Arts & Crafts 14kt Iridescent Art Glass "Man in the Moon" Pendant Arts & Crafts 14kt Iridescent Art Glass "Man in the Moon" Pendant Quick View

Arts & Crafts 14kt Iridescent Art Glass "Man in the Moon" Pendant

$1,295

A wonderful "Man in the Moon" pendant from the Arts & Crafts era (ca1900)! This whimsical compilation piece features an alluring art glass cen...
Victorian Petite 14kt Diamond Star Earrings Victorian Petite 14kt Diamond Star Earrings Quick View

Victorian Petite 14kt Diamond Star Earrings

$1,895

A gorgeous pair of diamond star earrings from the Victorian (ca1880s) era! Each 14kt gold earring forms a 6-point starburst, which is adorned with ...
Victorian 12kt/Silver Rose Cut Diamond Cluster & Pearl Fringe Earrings Victorian 12kt/Silver Rose Cut Diamond Cluster & Pearl Fringe Earrings Quick View

Victorian 12kt/Silver Rose Cut Diamond Cluster & Pearl Fringe Earrings

$1,395

A beautiful pair of hanging cluster earrings from the Victorian (ca1880) era! Each earring is crafted in 12kt gold and silver, and has an unusual d...
Victorian 14kt Banded Agate Watch Keys Fob/Pendant Victorian 14kt Banded Agate Watch Keys Fob/Pendant Quick View

Victorian 14kt Banded Agate Watch Keys Fob/Pendant

$1,295

Watch keys were not only designed for utility, but were often decorative pieces that doubled as pendants or fobs. They are still appreciated for t...
Victorian Gunmetal Watch & Niello Chain Necklace Victorian Gunmetal Watch & Niello Chain Necklace Quick View

Victorian Gunmetal Watch & Niello Chain Necklace

$1,295

Niello is a blackened substance, which is comprised of metallic alloys (such as copper, silver, and lead) mixed with sulphur. Like enamel, it serve...
Victorian 14kt Rock Quartz Crystal Teardrop Earrings Victorian 14kt Rock Quartz Crystal Teardrop Earrings Quick View

Victorian 14kt Rock Quartz Crystal Teardrop Earrings

$2,195

A gorgeous pair of rock quartz crystal earrings from the Victorian (ca1880s) era! Crafted in bright 14kt gold, the earrings have a lovely dangling ...
Victorian Sterling/14kt Diamond Starburst Pendant 1.50ctw Victorian Sterling/14kt Diamond Starburst Pendant 1.50ctw Quick View

Victorian Sterling/14kt Diamond Starburst Pendant 1.50ctw

$2,195

A spectacular diamond starburst from the Victorian (ca1880) era! This gorgeous piece is made of 14kt gold topped in sterling silver. The diamond-e...
Early Victorian Silver/14kt Gold & Diamond Safety Pin .40ctw Early Victorian Silver/14kt Gold & Diamond Safety Pin .40ctw Quick View

Early Victorian Silver/14kt Gold & Diamond Safety Pin .40ctw

$1,395

A stunning diamond safety pin from the Early Victorian (ca1850) era! This stylish antique piece is crafted in silver-topped 14kt gold. The design a...
HERMES Vintage Sterling Black & Yellow Enamel "Clic Clac" Bracelet HERMES Vintage Sterling Black & Yellow Enamel "Clic Clac" Bracelet Quick View

HERMES Vintage Sterling Black & Yellow Enamel "Clic Clac" Bracelet

$1,295

This vintage bracelet from the 1970s is a fabulous piece by legendary designer Hermes! Most of these bangles were not produced in sterling silver,...
FRANK GEHRY for TIFFANY & CO. Estate Sterling 7 Fish Necklace FRANK GEHRY for TIFFANY & CO. Estate Sterling 7 Fish Necklace Quick View

FRANK GEHRY for TIFFANY & CO. Estate Sterling 7 Fish Necklace

$1,095

Frank Gehry is a world famous Canadian-American architect. Known for his eccentric futuristic designs, Modernist influences, and curvilinear aesthe...
Vintage 18kt Gold & Moonstone Cufflinks Vintage 18kt Gold & Moonstone Cufflinks Quick View

Vintage 18kt Gold & Moonstone Cufflinks

$1,495

A wonderful pair of vintage moonstone cufflinks from the 1950s! Victorian (ca1880) era! These striking cufflinks are crafted in 14kt gold, and hav...
Victorian 9kt Natural Pearl Picture Frame 2.5" Diameter Victorian 9kt Natural Pearl Picture Frame 2.5" Diameter Quick View

Victorian 9kt Natural Pearl Picture Frame 2.5" Diameter

$1,595

A lovely pearl picture frame from the Victorian (ca1880) era! This beautiful round frame is made of solid 9kt gold and is decorated with 42 beautif...
Victorian Petite 14kt/Sterling & Diamond Crescent Necklace Victorian Petite 14kt/Sterling & Diamond Crescent Necklace Quick View

Victorian Petite 14kt/Sterling & Diamond Crescent Necklace

$1,295

A charming crescent necklace from the Victorian (ca1880) era! This lovely necklace consists of a petite crescent moon charm that hangs from a moder...
Victorian Large 14kt Onyx & Rose Cut Diamond "R" Locket/Pendant Victorian Large 14kt Onyx & Rose Cut Diamond "R" Locket/Pendant Quick View

Victorian Large 14kt Onyx & Rose Cut Diamond "R" Locket/Pendant

$1,895

An incredible onyx and diamond locket/pendant from the Victorian (ca1880) era! This impressive piece is carved from a solid piece of onyx, and is q...
Vintage 14kt Reverse Carved Crystal Horse & Buckle Cufflinks Vintage 14kt Reverse Carved Crystal Horse & Buckle Cufflinks Quick View

Vintage 14kt Reverse Carved Crystal Horse & Buckle Cufflinks

$1,395

Reverse carved crystal is a technique created by cutting rock quartz crystal into a convex form and then polishing it into a cabochon shape. An ima...
Victorian Large 15kt Gold Quartz & Fringe Pin/Pendant Victorian Large 15kt Gold Quartz & Fringe Pin/Pendant Quick View

Victorian Large 15kt Gold Quartz & Fringe Pin/Pendant

$1,395

Gold-in-quartz was formed while the earth was still in its molten state. During the cooling and solidification process, veins of gold became trappe...
Victorian 14kt Peridot Rose Cut Diamond Cluster Ring Victorian 14kt Peridot Rose Cut Diamond Cluster Ring Quick View

Victorian 14kt Peridot Rose Cut Diamond Cluster Ring

$1,295

An absolutely beautiful peridot and diamond cluster ring from the Victorian (ca1880) era! Made of 14kt rosy yellow gold, the ring has a very delica...
Edwardian Mixed Metals Garnet & Diamond Triple Snake Ring Edwardian Mixed Metals Garnet & Diamond Triple Snake Ring Quick View

Edwardian Mixed Metals Garnet & Diamond Triple Snake Ring

$1,495

The snake has been a powerful image since the Victorian era and continues to be popular even in modern jewelry. It has been an inspiration for jewe...
Victorian Silver Carved Moonstone & Turquoise Heart Necklace Victorian Silver Carved Moonstone & Turquoise Heart Necklace Quick View

Victorian Silver Carved Moonstone & Turquoise Heart Necklace

$1,395

A lovely moonstone necklace from the Victorian (ca1880) era! This beautiful piece is made of silver and is comprised of a delicate moonstone pendan...
Victorian Long Sterling Silver & Moonstone Chain Necklace 60" Victorian Long Sterling Silver & Moonstone Chain Necklace 60" Quick View

Victorian Long Sterling Silver & Moonstone Chain Necklace 60"

$1,495

A simply beautiful sterling and moonstone chain from the Victorian (ca1880) era! This stunning piece is comprised of smooth moonstone cabochons tha...
TIFFANY & Co. Estate Platinum Etoile Diamond Band 0.22ct TIFFANY & Co. Estate Platinum Etoile Diamond Band 0.22ct Quick View

TIFFANY & Co. Estate Platinum Etoile Diamond Band 0.22ct

$1,595

A stunning TIFFANY & CO. diamond band! Part of the Tiffany & Co. Etoile collection, this gorgeous piece has 10 sparkling brilliant cut dia...
Art Nouveau English 9kt Gold Moonstone Ring Art Nouveau English 9kt Gold Moonstone Ring Quick View

Art Nouveau English 9kt Gold Moonstone Ring

$1,095

A beautiful and feminine ring from the Art Nouveau (ca1910) era! This lovely piece is crafted in 9kt yellow gold and features a decorative centerpi...
Victorian 14kt Mississippi River Pearl Chain Necklace 56" Victorian 14kt Mississippi River Pearl Chain Necklace 56" Quick View

Victorian 14kt Mississippi River Pearl Chain Necklace 56"

$1,495

A beautiful Mississippi River pearl chain from the Victorian (ca1880) era! Extremely long in length, this necklace is made of sections of 14kt yell...
TIFFANY & CO. Estate 18kt Diamond 3-Band Rolling Trinity Ring TIFFANY & CO. Estate 18kt Diamond 3-Band Rolling Trinity Ring Quick View

TIFFANY & CO. Estate 18kt Diamond 3-Band Rolling Trinity Ring

$1,895

This diamond trinity ring is an estate piece signed by Tiffany & Co! Sometimes known as a "Rolling ring," "Roller Ring," or "Russian wedding ba...
Victorian 15kt Gold Etruscan Earring & Pin Boxed Set Victorian 15kt Gold Etruscan Earring & Pin Boxed Set Quick View

Victorian 15kt Gold Etruscan Earring & Pin Boxed Set

$2,495

A gorgeous boxed Etruscan jewelry set from the Victorian (ca1880) era! The 3-piece set is comprised of a pair of earrings and a complimentary brooc...
Art Nouveau 10kt Diamond & Filigree "Wings" Lavalier Necklace Art Nouveau 10kt Diamond & Filigree "Wings" Lavalier Necklace Quick View

Art Nouveau 10kt Diamond & Filigree "Wings" Lavalier Necklace

$1,295

A lovely lavalier necklace from the Art Nouveau (ca1910) era! This elegant piece is crafted in 10kt white gold, and is comprised of a shapely penda...
Victorian Sterling/14kt Hanging Urn Earrings Victorian Sterling/14kt Hanging Urn Earrings Quick View

Victorian Sterling/14kt Hanging Urn Earrings

$1,695

A beautiful pair of hanging urn earrings from the Victorian (ca1880) era! Each of these wonderful earrings is crafted in vibrant sterling silver wi...
Art Deco 18kt Turquoise & Rose Cut Diamond Ring Art Deco 18kt Turquoise & Rose Cut Diamond Ring Quick View

Art Deco 18kt Turquoise & Rose Cut Diamond Ring

$1,295

A gorgeous turquoise and diamond ring from the Art Deco era (ca1920)! This beautiful and feminine ring is crafted in 18kt white gold. A polished t...